Comparing Cars Essay

"Of the two leading car brands in the market today -- Sloda and Cosmic, Sloda is far superior. Sloda has a fuel economy of 22 m/gallon compared to Cosmic, which has 18 m/gallon under test conditions. The spare parts for Sloda are easily available in the metros and the after sales service offered by the company although expensive, is excellent. Sloda also costs $800 cheaper than Cosmic and is by far the most economical car in the market. It has a great resale value; I was able to sell my Sloda at a higher price than my neighbor's Cosmic V2."

Discuss how well reasoned you find this argument. (Time limit: 30 mins)

Many factors are taken into account before buying a car. Depending on the customer, these factors may range from cost and luxury to the resale value. These give rise to comparisons between the available models. But the comparison and the resulting assessment made by the author, that the model Sloda is a superior car than Cosmic in not justified. There are many flaws in the argument which must be resolved.

One of the premises that the author has considered is the mileage of the cars. Cars perform differently from test conditions when they run on different types of terrain. For example, a sedan is more economical in a city than on dirt roads and mountainous regions. In the latter conditions, an SUV is a better option. Therefore, the conclusion that Sloda has a better fuel economy is flawed as the author does not provide any information on the types of the cars and their intended terrain of usage.

Secondly, the author's attempt to highlight the availability of spare parts in metros is not very convincing. That is because it does not include small cities, villages and other remote areas. This cancels out the advantages of a reliable after-sales service in those areas.

Another flaw in the line of reasoning is in the statement of the resale value. The resale value of a car depends upon the usage and present condition of the car. So a new car usually has a higher resale value than an older one. Hence, the higher resale value of the author's Sloda than her neighbour's Cosmic V2 cannot be considered as a significant factor because the condition of the cars at the time of resale is unknown. In other words, there is no basis for such a comparison.

In conclusion, the author's argument seems a bit prejudiced to be taken seriously. Such an argument is only justifiable if the above mentioned loopholes are closed, and additional factors like luxury, customer satisfaction, etc are considered.

Hi, Ershad

Hope, the following suggestions would be useful:

Sloda also costs $800 cheaper than Cosmic and is by far the most economical car in the market.


Apart from discussed, you may say that Sloda is cheeper because there is low demand for this brand in the market, which has nothing to do with its superiority.

Sloda has a fuel economy of 22 m/gallon compared to Cosmic, which has 18 m/gallon under test conditions.


Also, cars are usually assessed on set of parameters. Although Cosmic's fuel economy is relatively low, at all other points it may surpass Sloda cars.

Hey, good job poking holes in that sales pitch, I couldn't think of anything!

The comparisons and the resulting assessment made by the author, that the model Sloda is a superior car than Cosmic, is not justified.

There are many flaws in the argument which must be resolved.

Therefore, the conclusion that Sloda uses less fuel is flawed, as the author does not provide any...

Another flaw in the authors line of reasoning is in the statement concerning the resale value.

A new car usually has a higher resale value than an older one, h ence, the higher resale value of the author's Sloda than her neighbour's Cosmic V2 cannot be considered a significant factor because the condition of the cars at the time of resale is unknown.

In conclusion, the author's argument seems a bit too prejudiced to be taken seriously.

Thanks both of you!

There are many flaws in the argument which must be resolved.


When you do your thesis statement at the end of that first paragraph, try this strategy:
Ask yourself, "If I wanted to express the meaning of the whole essay in a single sentence, what would that sentence say?"

End the first paragraph with a sentence that contains the essence of the essay, the DNA. It has to be a sentence that contains whatever particular truth makes the essay unique. Try to explain yourself fully in that one sentence, and then use the rest of the essay to clarify that assertion.

I know.

You've given me this advice before. But I can't seem to apply it :(

Can you give me an example? Let's say for this particular essay what should be the thesis statement?

Dear Hussain,

I think you should not take such a hard liner attitude on the topic. In critical reasoning questions try to avoid your own thoughts, use it for only proving your points. Try to concentrate on analyzing the issue and not giving too many comments. Try to develop your thoughts slowly and only towards the end of the essay give your verdict. Almost similar point Kevin has pointed out. Another problem that I find with your essay is of mannerism i.e., try to use some variation of the term flaw instead of using it so frequently. In third paragraph you are unable to make yourself clear. So, please read it aloud to yourself and try to modify it. No doubt, you have got almost all the contradiction right in the argument but try to develop it in a better way. For this read instruction of GRE to answer the argument section and try to get some suggestion from books on this topic. In these books, read, how to answer the argument essay. You can read sample essay by downloading, "An introduction to the analytical writting section of the GRE general test." from ETS website.

Best wishes,
Rajesh

Thanks Rajesh

I'll try to remember those points.

An example of a thesis... let me think of a magic word.

Okay, for the essay you wrote, I might write a thesis like this:
The argument about the superiority of the Sloda can be misleading, because each of the author's three points is contingent of certain circumstances.

The operative phrase is that "each point is contingent." I notice that your essay shows that each point the author makes is only true under some circumstances but not others. That is what contingency is. That's why I would use contingency as the THEME I give at the end of the first paragraph.

Use a magic word to burn your mark on the reader's mind. First there was the word, and the word was, etc. ... give a good word to capture the meaning, and it will be powerful communication. That is true in spoken and written communication. So, in your essay, the magic word might be contingent, and in this little blurb I am writing, the magic word is "magic word."

The magic word is what the reader will remember.

Thanks a lot man! I think I got what you mean.

The next time I will try to do that. Put that magical sentence :)



Comparison and Contrast of Two Car Advertisements

  • Length: 434 words (1.2 double-spaced pages)
  • Rating: Excellent
Open Document

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - More ↓
Comparison and Contrast of Two Car Advertisements

I am going to compare and contrast two TV car adverts. The first
advert is Fiat Stilo-sound effects and the second advert is Honda
Accord. I chose these adverts because the first time I saw them they
looked interesting and had a lot of differences between them.

The Fiat Stilo advert is 39 seconds long. It is aimed at 20-35 year
old male and female. It is a small affordable car suitable for working
class ordinary people. The advert is fast moving. There are four
characters in the advert. Three are male and one is female. Two of the
men and the women are around 25-35 years old but one of the men looks
much older around his 40's. The woman sits in the front drivers seat,
which makes her role look more secure than the men in the back. The
car also catches the attention of an elderly man whose sitting down
reading a newspaper. The characters investigate the car before driving
it. They press buttons, open windows and play with the seat to see
what each thing does.

Whereas the Honda Accord advert is 1 minute 58 seconds long and aimed
at 20-40 year old male and female probably with families because it is
quite a big car. The car is for middle-high class people. The advert
itself shows different car parts needed for the final making of the
car. In this advert the viewers do not know what is being advertised
until the very end. This is because the advertisers want to keep the
viewers in anxiety so that they keep on watching until the end of the
advert.

The Honda accord advert is longer than the Fiat Stilo advert and the
storyline of both adverts is very different because the Honda Accord
shows the parts needed for the making of the car and the Fiat Stilo
shows the finished car item and the parts inside the car such as the
automatic windows, navigator and the moveable seats. The Fiat Stilo
also has four characters that gives the viewers an idea what age group

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Comparison and Contrast of Two Car Advertisements." 123HelpMe.com. 10 Mar 2018
    <http://www.123HelpMe.com/view.asp?id=119368>.

LengthColor Rating 
A Comparison of Different Advertisements Essay - A Comparison of Different Advertisements The producers of advertisements in newspapers and magazines ensure that the image that they are trying to create makes a statement to their target audience. They make certain that the advert is vivid but clear so it will easily stick in the audience's mind. For the target audience, the car advertisements have a lot of influence over our decision on buying cars. The producers of the car adverts want us to feel that we as their target audience are missing out on their brand new superb cars....   [tags: Papers]2181 words
(6.2 pages)
Powerful Essays[preview]
Essay about Comparing Two Advertisements - Comparing Advertisements For this comparison I have chosen to compare two car adverts. The first advert I chose was from the car magazine "Autocar" and this is an advert for a Chrysler PT Cruiser. The second advert I chose was from the "Sunday Times" and this is for a Fiat Ulysse. I chose these two adverts because I feel that they will be good compare as they have similarities and differences so there are many things I can comment about. There is a big difference in the sale tactics of the 2 adverts....   [tags: Adverts, Compare and Contrast]613 words
(1.8 pages)
Strong Essays[preview]
Essay on Comparing Three Advertisements for Levi's Jeans - Levi's brand created an image of youth and freedom in the adverts. The American dream is normally created as a materialistic society in which people desire money and possessions; it is shown as a hot, sunny paradise. In many ways the Levi's adverts are associated with young, unconventional, even rebellious people of whom people are envious or disapproving. In the adverts the men are usually presented as rule breakers whom the women follow. In a reversal of the normal representation men are also presented as the object of sexual desire....   [tags: comparison, compare contrast]2444 words
(7 pages)
Powerful Essays[preview]
Essay on Comparisons of Advertisements - Advertising is important for every type of business in all types of sectors. It is important to be creative in these adverts and advertisers use a variety of different techniques in order to sell their products ahead of their competitors. In a market with many competitors it is even more important to have a creative advert, as there is so many other businesses the customer can go to for the same product or services. This is no different for a supermarket chain. The food retail sector is a major sector with lots of big companies competing for a share in the market....   [tags: business, adverts, advertisements, competitors]
:: 5 Works Cited
1010 words
(2.9 pages)
Better Essays[preview]
Comparison and Contrast in The Great Gatsby Essay - Comparison and Contrast in The Great Gatsby       The success of Francis Scott Key Fitzgerald's The Great Gatsby is in part due to his successful characterization of the main characters through the comparison and contrast of Daisy Buchanan and Myrtle Wilson, Tom Buchanan and George B. Wilson, and Nick Carraway and Jay Gatsby. The contrast is achieved through two principle means: contrasting opposite qualities held by the characters and contrasting one character's posititve or negative qualities to another's lack thereof....   [tags: comparison compare contrast essays]
:: 6 Works Cited
1767 words
(5 pages)
Powerful Essays[preview]
A Comparison of Two Car Advertisements: Ford Focus and Renault Megane Essay - A Comparison of Two Car Advertisements: Ford Focus and Renault Megane Advertising is a way of life and like it or not advertisements are going no where. What ever you do there will be some kind of advertising near by. For example, listening to the radio on the way to work is a way of advertising as advertisers use the radio as a common way to advertise. Some people take notice of these advertisements where as others believe they should be scrapped. In this essay I am going to compare to recent car adverts....   [tags: Papers]857 words
(2.4 pages)
Good Essays[preview]
Comparison of Two Advertisements Essay - Comparison of Two Advertisements First of all, I will look at the history of advertising. Most historians believe that the first adverts were signs hung above shop doors in Babylon, now Iraq. This was as early as 3000 B.C. Many people could not read, so these early adverts were often symbols, for example a boot indicated a shoemakers shop. The first mass advertisement in Britain was in about 1472, after Johannes Gutenburg had invented movable type. It was a poster advertising the sale of a book, and was stuck to church doors....   [tags: Papers]730 words
(2.1 pages)
Good Essays[preview]
A Comparison of Two Advertisements Essay - A Comparison of Two Advertisements I am going to compare the two advertisements l have been given, one is 'Save the children' and one is 'Barnardo's'. The points I am going to discuss are logo and contact information, slogan use of emotive language, use of repetition, pictures, use of 'you', message, appeal and target audience. The logo in the 'Save the Children' leaflet is the upper half of a body reaching upwards. It is encircled by a thick line with a gap before it reaches the body....   [tags: Adverts, Compare and Contrast]1015 words
(2.9 pages)
Strong Essays[preview]
A Comparison of Two Advertisements Essay - A Comparison of Two Advertisements The female advert could be aimed at middle aged women. This is because it is not showing a really young person in the mirror such as a teenager, and it looks like someone in their mid-twenties or early thirties. This might make it less appealing to younger people, because it does not have the “fun factor” such as funky designs. The male advert could be targeting an age group between 18 and 30 but older people possibly will be tempted to purchase the product, as it could make men feel strong and masculine because of the design of the bottle....   [tags: Compare Contrast Marketing Brand]1043 words
(3 pages)
Strong Essays[preview]
Essay on A Comparison of Two Advertisements - A Comparison of Two Advertisements Advertising is a tool used by businesses to inform us about their products and to persuade us to buy them. Advertisements are all around us: on billboards, in magazines, in newspapers, on the Internet, on airplanes, in shop windows, on posters and banners, on leaflets and so on. Advertisements attempt to persuade the subconscious that our lives would be improved if we bought the product on offer. Advertisements affect our lives because we see a product that we want and love so we buy it and when a new and better product comes along we push the old product to the back of the cupboard or even throw it away; this encourages...   [tags: Papers]1255 words
(3.6 pages)
Good Essays[preview]



the car is for. In this advert the car is for young trendy people and
probably some older people. On the other hand the Honda Accord has no
characters in the advert.

The Fiat Stilo background changes throughout the advert. At the
beginning the four characters come out of what looks like a terraced
house. Next they are seated in the car. When they start driving they
go past a big building and then you can see them crossing a bridge, it
looks like a city.

The background for Honda Accord is the same throughout the advert. It
is a wooden laminated floor with a cream colour wall.

The Fiat Stilo background is more interesting because it changes all
the time whereas the Honda Accord background stays the same throughout
the advert.

There are various camera shots used during the Fiat Stilo advert. The
camera uses long shots, mid shots and high angle shot. There is one
extreme close up as the man presses a start/stop button.

Camera shots used in the Honda Accord are mostly mid shots this shows
most of the part being shown. There are also two close ups one at the
beginning and one at the end where they show the dashboard and
steering wheel. The whole advert is made with pan shots.

The Fiat Stilo advert uses more camera shots than the Honda accord and
so it shows more views of the car than the Honda Accord.



0 Replies to “Comparing Cars Essay”

Lascia un Commento

L'indirizzo email non verrà pubblicato. I campi obbligatori sono contrassegnati *